Went To The Dark Side. . . . Drinkin' Bourbon!!!!!. . . And Lovin' It!!!!

We did a highly controlled taste test of various bourbons at the shop with 28 different brands!

We wear lab coats when we drink...... You know, because we're scientists. . . . Or is it that we're scientists because we wear lab coats ?:cool:

Either way the test results were VERY unexpected!

Rebel Yell came in near the top of everyone's list!!!:eek:

There were over 20 hardcore scientists (drunk Busse shop folk) who participated in these tests!!!

That's a lot of lab coats!:thumbup:

I'll try to find the results and post them here.

It was VERY scientific.... Did I mention that we wear lab coats?:D

Jerry:D




I'm with you on that. Rebel Yell is the best cheap bourbon I know, despite it's reputation as cheap bourbon.

Was Evan William's Single Barrel included I your test? Best cheap premium bourbon by a league (because a mile isn't enough), IMO. But I don't have a lab coat, so that's just an unscientific assessment.
 
I'm with you on that. Rebel Yell is the best cheap bourbon I know, despite it's reputation as cheap bourbon.

Was Evan William's Single Barrel included I your test? Best cheap premium bourbon by a league (because a mile isn't enough), IMO. But I don't have a lab coat, so that's just an unscientific assessment.


Well now, we need to define our terms.

Cheap.
Cheap premium.
Premium.

Aye, there's the rub. Where is the demarcation?
 
ok guys what do you think are 10 great bourbon whiskeys at under $60?
 
I have Brek and it is good. I think I have had buffalo trace as well. And I love Basel Hayden.
 
Basil Hayden is for weaklings. It's only 80 proof! Man up and drink Old Grand Dad 114 (same mash bill). It's not aged quite as long, but it's barrel-proof and costs half as much.

Elmer T. Lee is legit. Blanton's is okay, a bit overpriced.

Whoever mentioned Jack Barrel Proof, now that's a sleeper. Absolutely excellent (even though it's Tennessee whiskey). Get it while you can.

Jefferson Groth, I never had. But I heard good things.

Top Five Bourbons You Need to Try (And Won't Be Able to Find):
Russell's Reserve 1998 -- Came out this year, $250 a bottle. Best Bourbon Wild Turkey has ever made!!! Only 2,000 bottles released
John E. Fitzgerald -- $300-plus a pint! Also came out this year, also super limited release. It's like drinking angel tears.
William Larue Weller -- Part of the BTAC release. $80 retail. Consistently ranked as the best bourbon every year (yes, better than Pappy -- of course, it's made by the makers of pappy)
Pappy -- Yes, it's here because it is the best. If you ever had some, then you know what I'm talking about. If you haven't, then... don't bother looking for it.
Four Roses Limited Small Batch -- Another once-a-year-release. Around $120 per bottle. So good, so smooth, so flavorful.

Top Five Bourbons You Need to Try (and can find)
Booker's -- Beam puts out a lot of good stuff, including Knob Creek. But of all the juice in their lineup, Booker's is the way to go. No doubt.
Wild Turkey Rare Breed -- Like Booker's it's barrel-proof. It's complex, yet smooth. Highly versatile, net, rocks, mixer... it works anyway you want.
Elijah Craig 12 -- A bourbon aged 12 years for $30? It's an impossibly great value. But the jig is up. Soon, EC will no longer be aged 12 years, HH is disbanding its aged statement. Get it while you can.
Four Roses Single Barrel -- If you can't score the limited small batch release, try a bottle of single barrel.
Henry McKenna Single Barrel -- Bottled in Bond, aged 10 years (100 proof), around $30... need I go on?
 
Great list. If you think of some more post them. I am going to have a tasting with some friends and will be buying a few
 
$60? :eek: Please.

How about under $20, for us common folk.

Think of it as the Scrap Yard Bourbon thread. :D:thumbup::rolleyes:
 
I have a friend who turned me on to Henry McKenna, for the price it's my favorite. I'm loving these threads on what to have and it's description. Thanks guys
 
Pappy 12 and 23 were on our list of 28 as well as Jefferson Ocean, and Jefferson Groth.

I found Pappy 12 to be much better than the 23, but then again I'm a scotch guy!

I'll look for the list tomorrow along with results..

These were blind taste tests....

Lets drink!

Jerry
 
There are plenty of great bourbons under $60. Baker's, Rock Hill Farms, Angels Envy, Henry McKenna single barrel, Russell's Reserve single barrel, Russell's Reserve, Noah's Mill, Rowen Creek (better after it's had some air, IMO - I wasn't crazy about it at first; but really enjoyed it when I went back to it after a while. Now I cheat...I open and split the bottle), Elijah Craig 12, Buffalo Trace, Wild Turkey Rare Breed, WT Kentucky Spirit, John Bowman, Bowman Brothers, Breaking and Entering, Four Roses Small Batch, Woodford Reserve... I could keep going but you get the point.

My top 5 under $60: Rock Hill Farms, Henry McKenna single barrel, Buffalo Trace, WT Kentucky Spirit, and Baker's. Noah's Mill is up there, as well, and would have made the list if I hadn't found the H McK SB.
 
$60? :eek: Please.

How about under $20, for us common folk.

Think of it as the Scrap Yard Bourbon thread. :D:thumbup::rolleyes:

How about up to $30? Buffalo Trace, Henry McKenna SB, Elijah Craig, Four Roses Small Batch, and Old Grandad 114....then there's Evan Williams Single Barrel, Bowman Brothers, Jim Beam Black (8yr), Elmer T Lee, Maker's Mark, Larceny, and Breaking & Entering as a bonus. (I haven't bought B&E recently, but it was under $30 when I got it).
 
Last edited:
Pappy 12 and 23 were on our list of 28 as well as Jefferson Ocean, and Jefferson Groth.

I found Pappy 12 to be much better than the 23, but then again I'm a scotch guy!

I'll look for the list tomorrow along with results..

These were blind taste tests....

Lets drink!

Jerry

So the cheap whiskey beat pappy. I have to say when we got pappy last year and compared it to stranahans diamond peak, stranahans blew it away.
 
I am drinking Buffalo Trace and it is 10:30 AM, so I guess I will go with that, Cheers Boys and girls!!!
 
I generally drink Blanton when I drink bourbon, sadly my New Year's resolution was to go all of 2016 without hard alcohol.

This is a Beer only year for me.
 
I generally drink Blanton when I drink bourbon, sadly my New Year's resolution was to go all of 2016 without hard alcohol.

This is a Beer only year for me.

Whiskey is healthier than beer for you
 
Man, where's that HOG cunning that always beats me to the best INFI every time?

You guys need to apply your trough skills in other aspects of your lives.....

My entries for the best Busse Combat worthy bourbons:





Left to right:

Willett Family Reserve Barrel C13D, 21 yr
Pappy 15
Pappy 12
George T Stagg
 
Back
Top