I have a different theory on this. I have never seen one with an ash handle. I suppose they could have but at least most were hickory. Also, I have seen more than my fair share of E&S heads with perfect eyes, and many with wide eyes. As much as I love Oakland axes, and they are great, one area where they are sub par is how well they take abuse. I find the eye walls thinner and softer then typical, so they are more likely to start swelling out a bit if the poll is struck regularly. They are definitely axes for people that know how to use them correctly.