- Joined
- Jul 25, 2017
- Messages
- 2,462
I appreciate your craftsmanship in retoring those but I think those might not be worth the effort. The one with the failing forge weld has likely lost the last of its high carbon steel. The chipping pattern on the 2nd one suggests a bad heat treat. Your considerable skills might be better used on less used axes.
I say this as much for the benefit of the forum as for your benefit. I like to pick my battles.
I certainly appreciate the kind words and your point of view. This head was more a challenge, learning experience and effort for myself, knowing any mistakes made with a heavy hand, I could justify due to the condition I started with.
I felt I would have a good user, till I hit the peeling...than I just needed to follow thru and finish regardless with hope and optimism driving the 2nd filing.
Of which I really became hesitant and anxious to keep filing...but did.
Thank you @Square_peg. I certainly learned more for myself filing this ole boy but the forum can take from my example that though I found benefit and satisfaction from the work and discovery, it took time and a head I could offer up to practice on without much regard...I do have some sweet (IMO) axes that I hope will benefit from this experience when I file and hang.
Did you take all the hard steel off?Love that old straight handle looks good.
Thanks man! The handle is the inspiration for this little endeavor.
As far as hardness/high carbon steel remaining...a little perhaps, little to none maybe.
I cant say for certain that it will stand any real use or time out in the yard but it's got a great balance and did fly thru a little 4" limb without any rolling or noticeable dulling at the bit.

If anything, a display when its career is over...perhaps repurpose the haft at that point for a less used, more life left connie


Thank you guys
