What should a Bowie Knife be in 2026?

Monofletch said:
Just like this…..

View attachment 3169777
Click to expand...
This is just about the perfect proportions of a Bowie for today…….in my opinion only. More of a utility hunter or small camp knife, maybe for a soldier too. 5 to 6 inch blade, and while the above knife is modern, maybe something a lit to more classic with good lines. I have a Buck 117 in 5160 in a wood handle I want to try out, and my Mike Mann smaller Bowie with wood handle too.IMG_0747.jpeg



1777232193308.jpeg
 
Last edited:
eveled said:
The Bowie knife is lost to history, calling anything a Bowie is reducing history to a marketing tool.

It isn’t a tribute, it’s closer to stolen valor, maybe even cultural appropriation depending on who is doing it.
Click to expand...
Well, seeing as how no one knows what the the original looked like and that its prototypical pattern was quickly adopted by large scale makers such as Sheffield, the Bowie Knife IS a knife based in large part on marketing since the 19th century.

I can understand reverence for specific knives of special provenance or craftsmanship but the "appropriation" began long before even our grandfather's were born and, by this point, it is more historically accurate to use the name and style as it has been for generations now than to sequester the name away without even so much as an original.
 
We can get an idea what the original probably looked like based on the knives Rezin Bowie commissioned during the years. He was the knife man of the family, James just borrowed and fought with it -

images-q-tbn-ANd9Gc-Rx-Quf7u-J8s-Sf5SX-N7pa-Md-UMYXz-F-o-R-n0Q-s.jpg
.

images.jpg
.

Rezin's Chevalier commissioned Bowie -

bowie-knife-morphy-550.avif
.

---------------------------------------------

34 pages on the Edwin Forrest Bowie, it's a much more complex knife in construction than people give it credit for -

https://americansocietyofarmscollec...rrest-Bowie-Knife-Larson-expanded-version.pdf .
 
tltt said:
We can get an idea what the original probably looked like based on the knives Rezin Bowie commissioned during the years. He was the knife man of the family, James just borrowed and fought with it -

images-q-tbn-ANd9Gc-Rx-Quf7u-J8s-Sf5SX-N7pa-Md-UMYXz-F-o-R-n0Q-s.jpg
.

images.jpg
.

Rezin's Chevalier commissioned Bowie -

bowie-knife-morphy-550.avif
.

---------------------------------------------

34 pages on the Edwin Forrest Bowie, it's a much more complex knife in construction than people give it credit for -

https://americansocietyofarmscollec...rrest-Bowie-Knife-Larson-expanded-version.pdf .
Click to expand...
Excellent read. Thanks!
 
tltt said:
We can get an idea what the original probably looked like based on the knives Rezin Bowie commissioned during the years. He was the knife man of the family, James just borrowed and fought with it -

images-q-tbn-ANd9Gc-Rx-Quf7u-J8s-Sf5SX-N7pa-Md-UMYXz-F-o-R-n0Q-s.jpg
.

images.jpg
.

Rezin's Chevalier commissioned Bowie -

bowie-knife-morphy-550.avif
.

---------------------------------------------

34 pages on the Edwin Forrest Bowie, it's a much more complex knife in construction than people give it credit for -

https://americansocietyofarmscollec...rrest-Bowie-Knife-Larson-expanded-version.pdf .
Click to expand...
Great read, thank you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top