Which thumb nail do you use to open your slip-joint?

Which thumb nail do you use to open your knife?

  • Left

    Votes: 54 45.4%
  • Right

    Votes: 65 54.6%

  • Total voters
    119
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
the advantage is then offset by the risk of mishap during the handle transfer.
No risk, you still have ahold of the knife with your left hand while you slide your right hand down into position. You've never changed grips on a knife after opening it?

I'm curious what makes it more safe.
Two words... "Blood Zone".
The knife's sharpened edge or tip should never be pointed at any of your fleshy parts.
As a right handed person, opening the blade with the right hand, upward and away from the body, is safest.
 
I'll say that it's refreshing to have a spirited debate on the internet without any anger or hurt feelings.

... what's a "feeling"? I assumed we were all dead inside and coping by diving headlong into a knife obsession.

The knife's sharpened edge or tip should never be pointed at any of your fleshy parts.

I was just thinking about this the other day- I understand why they'd teach that, it's what I learned, but that's not always true, is it?
I think of how I carve opposite sides of faces; there are just times when the only way to cut something is to perform a parring cut.
I slowed me way down in my whittling journey. I even tried carving left handed so I could avoid that.
 
Doesn't matter if you use your right hand or left hand to open the knife, it's still a two-handed knife (for most) and you'll still have to remove one or the other before it's "ready to use"... so having the handle in your right hand doesn't really save any time.
Besides, if that really is a deciding factor, they make knives that can be used with only one hand... even "faster" more "tactical". ;) :D

My 60+ years of experience tell me otherwise, my knife is in a ready to use position as soon as the blade opens, no repositioning needed. FWIW I also pull sheathed knives out with my right hand so the knife is ready to use immediately.
 
No risk, you still have ahold of the knife with your left hand while you slide your right hand down into position. You've never changed grips on a knife after opening it?


Two words... "Blood Zone".
The knife's sharpened edge or tip should never be pointed at any of your fleshy parts.
As a right handed person, opening the blade with the right hand, upward and away from the body, is safest.
Interesting. I'm sitting here, opening a knife both ways...

I guess I see what you mean, if I imagine someone running and slamming into my back at the exact moment I've got the blade halfway opened. I tend to hold the handle at an angle that has the sharp edge facing downwards and away from me, so it doesn't feel too risky.

Looks like we lefties are losing the poll, but the good news is I don't have to change unless I want to. :D
 
I have been practicing using my left thumbnail (or pinch grip) to open the knife while holding it on my right hand.

While I "technically" end up with the knife in my dominant had I still have to rotate it in order to use it which I find slow and cumbersome.

Notice the rotation once the knife is opened.

q4QMSDI.gif


When doing it the "right" way LOL :D I find the knife ends up perfectly positioned to be used and lowering the right hand to grab the handle seems faster and more efficient to me ( notice that I am not transferring the knife from left to right,... if anything the knife is already more on my right hand by the time the opening motion is completed)

HqdlWuv.gif
 
Last edited:
It's all a question of harnessing your instinct ;) not listening to scoutmasters or other fonts of received wisdom :D
If you're ambidextrous like I am, you tend to have confident grip with either hand, most other people don't, but with knives I prefer holding them in the right so opening with the left is the instinct. As for safety...;) it's highly debatable , I hold a knife vertically so yes a charging bull or maniac might slam into my back while I'm opening it and for a nano second the tip might be exposed to a fraction of the body:rolleyes: But, you're even more likely to drop the knife on your feet or nether parts while transferring it from weaker hand to dominant one ;):eek:

We all need to abandon fingernail pulling knives and hand gymnastics and stay with fixed blades forever :D
 
I guess I'm a left-thumber sometimes anyway. Not all of my 2-bladed knives have the secondary in front (the correct way! :p), so there's that. And I still gotta think things over a bit whenever I grab a stockman...:confused::D
 
Okay, you caught me... it does take a fraction of a second and an extra step to slide your right hand down to the handle... :rolleyes:

And it takes an extra step to take the knife out of the slip, but who cares, you're in the Traditional Knife Zone?! :cool: Ah, an opportunity to use your knife. You take the beautifully-crafted leather slip from your pocket, run your hand over the edges, admire the skill that went into its manufacture. Slowly take the knife from the slip...ahhh...doesn't that feel good? Admire the beauty of it, run your fingers over the covers, delight in how lucky you are to have such a great knife, don't rush. You open the blade, enjoying the tension of the spring, and the familiar snap. Now you're ready. It's one of the great moments of your day, why would you want to hurry it? ;) :thumbsup:
 
And it takes an extra step to take the knife out of the slip, but who cares, you're in the Traditional Knife Zone?! :cool: Ah, an opportunity to use your knife. You take the beautifully-crafted leather slip from your pocket, run your hand over the edges, admire the skill that went into its manufacture. Slowly take the knife from the slip...ahhh...doesn't that feel good? Admire the beauty of it, run your fingers over the covers, delight in how lucky you are to have such a great knife, don't rush. You open the blade, enjoying the tension of the spring, and the familiar snap. Now you're ready. It's one of the great moments of your day, why would you want to hurry it? ;) :thumbsup:

This is the most sensual thing I've ever read about a knife.
Just imagine how many hearts this guy broke through the years!
 
but that's not always true, is it?
Let's not open up this discussion to varying shades of grey... stick with black or white, yes or no, right or wrong. :D

my knife is in a ready to use position as soon as the blade opens
Like Will says below, we should all be carrying fixed blades for the ultimate in speed and availability. :D

the good news is I don't have to change unless I want to.
Goodness, I hope nobody takes all thi seriously and tries to change anything. ;)

Notice the rotation once the knife is opened.
Seems dangerous to me. :D

I find the knife ends up perfectly positioned to be used and lowering the right hand to grab the handle seems faster and more efficient to me
Seems much safer to me. :D

We all need to abandon fingernail pulling knives and hand gymnastics and stay with fixed blades forever
I like this solution... but hip carry, pocket carry, cross draw, or some other? ;)

who cares, you're in the Traditional Knife Zone?
and not in the "Blood Zone" ;) :D

Ah, an opportunity to use your knife. You take the beautifully-crafted leather slip from your pocket, run your hand over the edges, admire the skill that went into its manufacture. Slowly take the knife from the slip...ahhh...doesn't that feel good? Admire the beauty of it, run your fingers over the covers, delight in how lucky you are to have such a great knife, don't rush. You open the blade, enjoying the tension of the spring, and the familiar snap. Now you're ready. It's one of the great moments of your day, why would you want to hurry it?
Perfectly said. If I need fast, Spyderco makes a better option. ;)
I'll listen to Jack, slow down and enjoy the process. It's the best part about using a traditional slip-joint knife.

I hope nobody takes any of this seriously, I really don't care which way you open your folder.
I use both hands... Shhhhhh... but I use the right one predominantly.
 
Unless you have a cat.
To be fair- we don't know R8shell's reasons. Perhaps she has a cat she likes to keep entertained, and the cost of a dozen unrolled TP tubes a week is nothing when considering the happiness of her cat.

A cat which also likely opens it's traditional slip joints with it's left paw.
 
I have been practicing using my left thumbnail (or pinch grip) to open the knife while holding it on my right hand.

While I "technically" end up with the knife in my dominant had I still have to rotate it in order to use it which I find slow and cumbersome.

Notice the rotation once the knife is opened.

q4QMSDI.gif


When doing it the "right" way LOL :D I find the knife ends up perfectly positioned to be used and lowering the right hand to grab the handle seems faster and more efficient to me ( notice that I am not transferring the knife from left to right,... if anything the knife is already more on my right hand by the time the opening motion is completed)

HqdlWuv.gif
Yes yes, but more importantly how many eye rolls did your camera person give you while videoing your knife "silliness" :rolleyes::rolleyes:

:D:thumbsup:
 
There you have it: it's simple math! :D

So, we've established that opening the blade with the right thumbnail is less efficient. I'm curious what makes it more safe. :confused: I can't really see how using ones dominant hand thumb gives better blade control. Even if it did, the advantage is then offset by the risk of mishap during the handle transfer.

I'll say that it's refreshing to have a spirited debate on the internet without any anger or hurt feelings. All in good fun, unlike the critical argument about which way the toilet paper roll should hang. (Over. The correct answer is over.)
Now that is a " Critical Argument " There is only ONE way for it to hang .
Harry
 
I have been practicing using my left thumbnail (or pinch grip) to open the knife while holding it on my right hand.

While I "technically" end up with the knife in my dominant had I still have to rotate it in order to use it which I find slow and cumbersome.

Notice the rotation once the knife is opened.

q4QMSDI.gif


When doing it the "right" way LOL :D I find the knife ends up perfectly positioned to be used and lowering the right hand to grab the handle seems faster and more efficient to me ( notice that I am not transferring the knife from left to right,... if anything the knife is already more on my right hand by the time the opening motion is completed)

HqdlWuv.gif
Looks like two perfectly reasonable ways to open a knife. I don't know how to record or post a video, but I'll say when I have the blade securely pinched with my left thumb and finger, I then wrap my right hand around the handle as it finishes snapping open. Not sure if I'm describing it well, but it's not quite as exaggerated a rotation as your first gif.
Unless you have a cat.

tenor.gif
To be fair- we don't know R8shell's reasons. Perhaps she has a cat she likes to keep entertained, and the cost of a dozen unrolled TP tubes a week is nothing when considering the happiness of her cat.

A cat which also likely opens it's traditional slip joints with it's left paw.
Ha! Fortunately, she hasn't learned either of those tricks, yet.
Goodness, I hope nobody takes all thi seriously and tries to change anything.
:D:thumbsup:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top