2011 Forum Knife Discussion Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ok guys, I'm going to put this to bed since I did the post with the pattern choices for the BF Knife. I said to not vote in the poll if you would not be purchasing a 2011 knife. Perhaps I should have clarified, but I didn't think people would get into a gripe over it. I did not want people who had absolutely no interest in ordering a 2011 knife to vote in the thread just for sh$ts and giggles. My intention was not to say that if you voted, you must buy a knife or we will hunt you down and ruin your life. It was meant to keep randoms from ruining it for the rest of you.

I understand if you didn't vote for the caplifter, don't like the caplifter, and don't want to buy the knife now. I'm fine with that and so is everybody else. I needed to have an estimate when I was in discussion with GEC about our quote. If GEC is going to spend thousands of $$$ of its own money to get ready to manufacture this knife, they need to know potential orders. If I told them we would probably have an order for 15 knives, then they would say "Ok...that's fine, but each knife will cost you $1000 each." After I looked at the number of people who voted in the polls, as Chris alluded to earlier, I anticipated that a certain percentage of voters would not order a knife, and that is the number I took to GEC. The number I gave to GEC was about 20-25% lower than the total number of votes. This was necessary and it is what it is.

So let's move on from the topic and talk about the attributes of the knife and the good/bad of the pattern. Nothing more needs to be said about the voting process for either the knife or the labels. It's distracting and just makes our job more difficult.
 
Got your 3 trey, wow! thanks for ordering a grip of 'em!

got your 1 synghyn!

Thanks guys.


Once I get a MO from Glennbad (ordering 2 I think?) this brings us to 116, but I am counting a couple eggs instead of chickens, 114 is official but I am sure 116 is real as rain.
 
This knife is going to be great! I always make sure to have a good quantity of small brewery holiday ale on hand for Christmas and the bottles always need a caplifter. Really looking forward to cracking the forum knifes first frosty ale.
 
Jack,

I can see how that perception was communicated. The last thing we wanted to create was ill will. In our want to find out about how many knives we could tell a cutlery to manufacture and get a solid quote out of them is what our primary intention was, which led us to communicate as we did. We felt, if we could count x # of EO jacks with cap lifter voted in the poll, we could say we hoped it yielded 90% of knives sold of that pattern. Somehow, we lost the devil in the details and did not communicate as we should have. Hopefully the 2012 crew can learn from our errors.

No ill will from me. The 2009 Barlow wouldn't have made my top 10 either, but it seems to have taken up permanent residence in my pocket anyway. :D
 
I just ordered three more. I don't know why I need 5 of them but I do.

Left front pocket, right front pocket, left back pocket, right back pocket and watch pocket. I think that's five. ;)

Seriously though... it's always good to have backup. I thought I lost my GEC Calf Roper on Sunday. I ended up finding it in another coat pocket but I was glad that I have another one just in case!
 
This is the first knife I've been excited about in a while. I'm going to love this one.

By Christmas most of us will be sitting on plastic chairs in a circle introducing ourself by first name and telling our story! :D

one-flew-over-the-cuckoos-nest.jpg
 
Robert B
Ed T
Meako
LKJW
Berkley
PG5768
Flying guilotine
Modoc Ed
Cnas120
Kreole
Mikeymoto
AiryQ
Dannyp
esevato
janekc
2dead
The Government
Coyote 711
Vege Taco
Rail Splitter
Jacall
Black Mamba
knowtracks
lava lamp
Bastid
Peruna 1998
comoha
alfaholic
Totally Judy
Ben B
Yablanowitz
TimCSaw
Waynorth
WA Martin
Campbellclanman
trey999
Dave T63
Oxbld
theblindog
Elron1
Michael Berkovitch
Scalprum
Jazub
Boggs
Contained
Winterminute
Brian T
mhawg
danno50
Jbrew2007
Kimsalls
Supratentorial
CWL
Daniel Dorn
Lmleck
Pwcb2005
Woodgood
Old Rifleman
Freezergeezer
Sextant
K-Lastima
Georgecatl
Warrior Sociologist
Steven Kelby
Protourist
Slider817
Phils@kentuckygrower
Oeser
Mqqn
CJ65
reader1
Thawk
rbmcmjr
Oliver H
Bruce Colberson
Urza
Paul M
Eswartz
CDHumiston
robot37
Willgoy
trey999 (another 3)
Synghyn
Glennbad


New total paid is 117!

K Lastima, your MO is deposited, the teller was fine with it. Glennbad, yours is in too! Trey, what can I say, you are awesome! 5 knives!
 
PP sent! I thought I was going to miss out on this one this year. Giri-giri safe.
 
Payment sent for one knife. Wish I had enough spare cash to order more, but one will have to do me I guess.

ED J
 
PP sent! I thought I was going to miss out on this one this year. Giri-giri safe.
Way cool Chinpo! Glad you are on board! I hope Japan is healing from the earthquakes, at least emotionally.
 
PP sent!

I don't think we need to tally votes vs. knives just yet. I voted last week, knowing that I wouldn't pay until today, but that I would be purchasing a knife before the order period expired (this will be my 5th year). I think extra votes means purchasing will continue right up to the deadline--maybe not everybody, but I bet most do, and the others probably just can't scrape together funds. After that the weeping, wailing and gnashing of teeth begin from those who delayed. :-)
 
PP sent!

I don't think we need to tally votes vs. knives just yet. I voted last week, knowing that I wouldn't pay until today, but that I would be purchasing a knife before the order period expired (this will be my 5th year). I think extra votes means purchasing will continue right up to the deadline--maybe not everybody, but I bet most do, and the others probably just can't scrape together funds. After that the weeping, wailing and gnashing of teeth begin from those who delayed. :-)

Robb,

I agree and hope you are right. We are still experiencing steady (a bit slow but steady as she goes) sales. I expect a last minute rush. We may choose to send out reminders, just in hopes people that do want a knife, do not miss out because they forgot.
 
Gorgeous!! Thank you. Those scales are amazing--just right for the shield and easy-open notch.
 
IMHO it's just about as close to perfection as you can get. Come, Christmas, come!

Does anyone who has one of these type EOs use the cutout for a finger hold? Seems like a natural.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top