The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details:
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.
Probably the wrong time and wrong thread to ask but..
What could be more "tactical" than a big ol' Bagwell Hell's Belle ?
Doug
No Kevin
I am promoting my friends and that is plain and simple
I take no joy in seeing anything that is not positive happening to the world of forged blades
But my phone was ringing after this show and what I am saying is flat out the truth. Poor attendance..... slow sales this was the word on this show. It's the truth
I'm a realist and I don't sit back and say no there is nothing wrong .....everything is great when there is obviously a problem
This is reality
I do not care if pink toe nail clippers were all the rage I would tell my friends in that business to cash in and feed their families
You must cater to an up and coming market
It does not matter what you do you must yield to the times
It bums me out because you think I derive pleasure in this because I speak it. If you see something and you talk about it hoping to see something change for the better you are wishing bad in some way ?
Talk to anybody in this industry and see where it is going
You can be like water and flow or you can be ridged and break
Just because I like ABS style blades and this is what I put my money into does not mean my taste is the be all end all
Someone as smart as you knows you can not fix a problem without realizing what the problem is
When is the last ABS dinner you attended ?
Your seeing the same thing I am
There are shows that are experiencing growth and that are seeing new faces and money
If the ABS does not do something to change things it will get no better. Till they figure out how to attract new buyers and new money the problem will only get worse
I'm sorry if I have upset you with my comments but I stand by them.
Having an MS stamp on your knife does not mean what it used to and that's a shame
Jim, I agree with your opening post 100%.
IMO, no one should be surprised that the popularity of tactical knives (folders & fixed-blades) has taken off so dramatically. Part of this popularity can be contributed to post-911. Look how firearm ownership has increased. Then theres the crave for high-tech anything, Hollywoods promotion of tactical weapons in popular action/hero movies, video games etc. and of course the popularity of folders in general.
Even though my interest (from a collecting perspective) is more towards traditional custom knives, as president of a knife collectors association whose members represent the entire customs community, Im thrilled to see this excitement and energy elevating tactical folders thus custom knives in general.
I would like to hear opinions on the expected longevity of the popularity of the tactical market?
Do you feel its here to stay, or possibly a phase?
As far as more traditional custom knives (ABS Bowies, Art knives and especially traditional Hunting knives), I feel no one needs to worry about these going away, as theres just too much rich tradition and heritage surrounding them. Actually, traditional makers transiting over to offering more tactical knives to their clients could have a positive effect on the traditional market from a supply & demand perspective.
Great thread Jim!
Tactical or otherwise if the knife buyers are not there knives don't sell. Coop, I will take that bet. I do know makers that sold thier knives as soon as they got home. The buyers are out there but I don't have the answers to get them to travel. Maybe part of it is that flying is so painful.
This is a good discussion, one that needs to be had....again.
The momentum that the Knifemaker's Guild had in the mid '90's and the American Bladesmith Society had in the early 2000's is GONE!
Why? Because those in leadership were more interested/hamstrung by "tradition" and "the way we have been doing things" and "our mission....." than seeing which way the wind was blowing, taking advantage of that momentum and making strategic decisions and planning for the sustainable EXPANSION of the organizations.
It is simply time for new leadership(yes, Gene you CAN do this, you are a smart and capable man) in BOTH organizations to scrap many of the "traditional" ways of doing things and redefine the goals of those organizations.
Specifically pointing to the ABS and state that the goal of "preserving the forged blade through education" is tired and OVER. It is time for the organization to recognize the rock stars of the forged blade, learn from them, promote them, and focus on the PROFITABILITY and inherent sexiness of the forged blade. The collection of knives in this issue of the ABS Journal focusing on knives done in the style of the 19th century only illustrates the problem all too well. MAYBE 5% of the collectors that I know even have a passing interest in this style of knife, but many makers do. It is self-indulgent.
I can point to the work of Adam and Haley DesRosiers, Matt Diskin, Burt Foster, Don Hanson, Jason Knight, David Mirabile, Mike Quesenberry and Nick Wheeler...just to name a few. Young, dynamic, always improving, always taking chances. Their knives command very respectable money, sell readily and they benefit the ABS by association, vastly more than they benefit from the ABS. It is jealousy, lack of comprehension and poor marketing/understanding of business that does not allow many of their peers to benefit from their examples. Their skills are light years ahead. I have seen very few makers produce a large fighter in the style of the makers mentioned above because it is pretty darned difficult....but it isn't impossible....the other makers just need to try, and try hard. Better to make one or two superlative piece(s) in a month for good money, than make 6 average pieces for average money.
Matt Diskin and I went to the Las Vegas Antique Arms and Armor Show at the Riviera on Saturday. I made a joke that many of the vendors must have purchased these items new. There were very few younger people in the room at all. Prices in many cases were fair..but the "action" wasn't there..the custom knifemakers section was small, not much exciting to see....simply old and tired. Contrast this with the TKI which ROCKED, great attendance, money being spent, great food, excellent vibe in the room for the collectors, dealers AND makers. Risks were taken, I mean Allen Elishewitz made a subhilt SWORD....and it sold for $3,800.00 Readily...and it will probably be re-sold for a profit.
As a maker, as a show promoter and as an organization head, if you are not focused on profitability for yourself, those that attend your shows and those that belong to your organization, you are an anachronism, and it is time to get out of the way, and let those who ARE working for EVERYONE's best interest to step up and lead.
As with Joe and Kevin, this is written as a fan of the forged blade....there are probably more forged blades in my collection than stock removal. Some nice swords, fixed blades and a few folders....many of these were in the mid-4 figures....I have love and skin in this game and only want everyone to share the joy that we all have for the forged blade.
Best Regards,
STeven Garsson
Let's discuss what might work
The TKI had a line to get in and I believe almost everything in the room sold
People had to fly to get there
A lot of people where in town already for the SHOT show
Some promoter was pretty smart to piggy back off the largest trade show for guns in the worldway to go Steve
By the way do you all know what is predominately the number one firearms at the shot show ....... Yes the dreaded black Rifle not flintlocks. This is to the tune of like 70 % black rifles. Again I am a collector of fine double rifles and shotguns not AR's but i would be blind to not see at I am the minority not the majority
Another thing every time an ABS maker makes a synthetic handle material or a brut deforged blade there is someone that thinks they are denigrating the stamp by making a knife that is affordable and might be desired by a younger buying market
Please except that people have different tastes and that tastes can change
Lets look at production knife companies. What artists are they working with ? Not many ABS smiths are they
They are catering to an up and coming market which regretfully is not ABS style blades
This is not personal. Its business
Again I am not saying that a maker that has a long wait and has a large following change a thing but if I were a young ABS style maker looking to feed my family I would be dabbling in many different genres to see what is growing and what is not
Kevin my dear friend, it still bothers me that you think I find any enjoyment in the lack of interest in the ABS shows. If anything I would like to see every genre from the art knife to the traditional folder market grow
#4
Participation?
For any show to be great you need maker participation. Sadly so many makers love to tout their Master Smith stamp and stamp every knife they make. But they can't find a way to attend the only all forged blade show in the world. And so many makers bitch about not selling knives at a show. But rarely stop to ask what they did to make the show better. How many collectors did they bring? How many collectors names did they supply to the committee for mailings?
THIS IS THE PROBLEM.....if you as a Board Member are so sure of your position that you don't consider other valuable and educated opinions, you harm yourself which is bad enough....but the egomania and damage you do to that organization is a killer....and you should get smart and consider those other opinions or step down....simple as that.#5
The ABS
I've gone to bat for the ABS a lot in public. And have again here a bit. But let me be clear. I have big concerns for the ABS and its future. I will not voice them here as I would rather do it directly to the board. But many of their board members are rigid and show no interest in listening to some of the younger makers. In fact I personally went to the board a few years ago and had a not so pleasant exchange. This is not the board as a whole. But certain key members of the ABS board are unwilling to listen to differing opinons.
Josh, it isn't a money thing....if you saw the money being spent at SHOT and The TKI, you would know this....it is a perception issue, possibly one of timing and it is a matter of makers marketing themselves to their best potential....but I do think the ABS needs to do more than the have done already and this requires a complete paradigm shift. I have no interest in traveling to Arkansas at this time, but do hear it is a bang up show.Sales at this years show were down a bit. But I don't think it was bad. In fact I thought the venue, room, and set up was quite nice. Sadly it seems as though the ABS is a bit fractured and unsure of its direction. Hopefully the ABS board will begin to reach out and realize they have some huge opportunities to expand and be a force in the knife world.