Be Honest... Would you pay $625 for this knife?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't think the price is too high for a big chopper, as long as the design/materials are there.

I've spent more on a Busse Fusion Battle Mistress Limited Edition. It was a tough user. So I'm not opposed to the price.

Winkler knives have a good rep.
 
In a word. No. Absolutely not. I don't care what steel it is. There just isn't that much work in that knife to justify that kind of price.
 
If it were completely handmade by him I could understand the price. It might possibly even be desirable at that price.

But it's not.
 
I'm bot looking for such a knife but if I were and had the funds (1) I would be willing to pay a premium so that the maker could offer it to servicemembers at a price within their budget, IF (2) the knife were actually a great performer for those servicemembers - and the performance of this knife can't be based on someone's experience with the steel from another maker/company, unless Winkler uses an identical grind geometry and heat-treat, which I suspect he doesn't.
 
Nice knives...But I'd buy a $650 Miller Bros Blades 3v chunk of destruction for that price. I have no problem dumping cash on quality cutting tools. Heck, I edc a Strider SMF, a Spartan Enyo, and a Spyderco Manix 2.
 
Well, I am new around here, but $600 in the world of Kitchen knives gives you 240mm fully hand made (forged) knife by well know masters as Kato or Shigefusa. When I compare that level of precision (little details matter a lot in performance of kitchen knives) that I would say - No, I do not see the value of the knife shown anywhere close to $600.
 
Disclaimer:

I do not know anything about the OP's original knife posted.

I do not own a $500. or a $1,000. knife. My husband does not own a $1000. knife either.

Now, with that said, IF I found a knife that I absolutely had to HAVE (THE ONE SPECIAL KNIFE as in some of my former firearms especially when I owned/shot handguns and a few rifles.) or one for my husband that HE dearly loved and wanted... I would go up to $500. for THE KNIFE. $500. and UP is nothing for a quality NIB firearm. Your mileage may vary. NO problem!

Look at what NIB good quality - name brand firearms cost years ago or even now. Same thing in my head - your mileage may vary.

A few of the older hunting knives that my husband has that you can't BUY the EXACT one any longer in a few name brands cost big money now... not $500. but close to or over $300. USED. He bought a few of those knives NIB years ago. HIS knives do get used and they are in very good condition. He does not abuse them but he does USE them when he hunts.

So if HE or I had to HAVE or WANTED ONE SPECIFIC quality knife... we would BUY that knife just as we would a piece of our quality made furniture that gets USED on a daily basis.

Wants and Needs are two different things in my mind.

Are you depending on and using a specific tool for military survival? Your life depends on this tool.

Are you depending on a KNIFE where you can't use a firearm to protect your life or a loved one?

What about any other tool when it comes to hard core survival in horrific conditions?

Are you making your living using a specific tool or tools? Do you want something that will last you for a long time or a throw away item or something that may FAIL you in the middle of a job?

Do you only want ONE or FIVE of these knives in your life or many, many knives made by various knife makers and in many styles and finishes?

Different strokes for different folks is my motto. Buy and use what trips your trigger. It is your money and until someone ELSE puts a roof over your head, clothes on your back and food in your belly... buy and own what you like and will use. Keep your basic obligations taken care of and exercise personal responsibility in all things.

Several years ago, I almost had a 'cardiac arrest' when my husband came home with a NIB small Damascus blade made by a well known knife maker. This blade had NO handle on it at the time because my husband had not decided what he wanted on it at the time. When he told me what he paid for it - I thought that it was HIGH but I did NOT know what prices were for some BLADES especially specific blades. Since that time frame, he had a pretty walnut handle put on it and I picked out the walnut wood from many samples. A local man that makes knives made the handle for this blade. IT is beautiful and boy oh boy - is it STRONG too! You could not find a knife made exactly like this simple, quality made knife. Maybe something close to it but not exactly like it. Now, if I saw this knife NOW - it would cost more due to the price of good steel (Damascus) and made by the same man not counting the handle too.

Cate
 
Last edited:
Knives come last on my priority list. If my budget allows I pick up a few. I personally would not spend that much on that knife due to my budget/income. Now, if I made 6 figures a yr and was out of debt, sure I'd look into it, but I still probably wouldn't buy because I have no need for it.
 
No. 1) My wife would kill me. 2) Even w/o #1, I wouldn't spend that much on a knife. I'd buy a Becker + handgun for $625.

Lets face it, when you are talking custom knives, you are paying for the name attached to it. I like Bob Loveless knives but I wouldn't drop 3 grand on one.

This might all change if I win 200 mil in the lottery.
 
I think Mr. Winkler is selling to military guys and guys who want gear like the military guys. If you want to be in that club you have to pay admission. One way or
another.

Hmmmm. Let's see. Should I put my own bacon on the line and be a operator or should I spend hundreds on a "Tool of the trade" so I just look "badass"? Several knife companies making a living on that decision, from BudK to Strider.
 
Be honest... why whine about some knife you probably never intended on buying anyway?

Winkler makes good stuff. This particular model is too long for my needs and I don't care for the sheath very much. If I needed a knife of that size
I might purchase it. I like his work and I trust his quality. Is it a little steep for what it is? Yes. Do we all buy knives considered to be at ridiculous prices
by normal peoples' standards? Yes.

Mr. Winkler also gives the best military discount in the business allowing his offerings to be much more affordable to our people in uniform. It's the same principal
as people wanting the oakleys offered to military members/vets from oakley standard issue. If you aren't a member you have to buy them elsewhere, at full price.
I think Mr. Winkler is selling to military guys and guys who want gear like the military guys. If you want to be in that club you have to pay admission. One way or
another.

If you are happier with your (insert product here) then go play with it and be happy. No reason to start a whine thread about a knife that you have no interest in.

This. This thread seems to have degenerated into a series of "Well, I'd never pay..." as though that's some huge slam on Winkler's work. The guy asks what he asks because he can, because people buy his products at those prices. It's the same reason why Chris Reeve charges north of $400 for a pocket knife.

What I find entertaining is that this thread has been fairly civil, due to it being about a maker who's not often discussed here. Want to see fireworks? Make this thread about one of the more expensive Busse knives out there! The mods would sail in off the top rope with the Peoples' Elbow to put the kibosh on this thread quick. LOL
 
Well, I am new around here, but $600 in the world of Kitchen knives gives you 240mm fully hand made (forged) knife by well know masters as Kato or Shigefusa.

Daniel Winkler is well-known and an ABS Master Bladesmith.
 
Being a ABS Master Bladesmith DOES make a difference. I would pay $1000 easily for something I really like made by a master. But those kind of bucks are hard to scrap up just to dump on a knife that I likely will never sharpen or use.
 
This. This thread seems to have degenerated into a series of "Well, I'd never pay..." as though that's some huge slam on Winkler's work. The guy asks what he asks because he can, because people buy his products at those prices. It's the same reason why Chris Reeve charges north of $400 for a pocket knife.

What I find entertaining is that this thread has been fairly civil, due to it being about a maker who's not often discussed here. Want to see fireworks? Make this thread about one of the more expensive Busse knives out there! The mods would sail in off the top rope with the Peoples' Elbow to put the kibosh on this thread quick. LOL


Would you personally pay $625 for this specific knife?
 
This. This thread seems to have degenerated into a series of "Well, I'd never pay..." as though that's some huge slam on Winkler's work. The guy asks what he asks because he can, because people buy his products at those prices. It's the same reason why Chris Reeve charges north of $400 for a pocket knife.

What I find entertaining is that this thread has been fairly civil, due to it being about a maker who's not often discussed here. Want to see fireworks? Make this thread about one of the more expensive Busse knives out there! The mods would sail in off the top rope with the Peoples' Elbow to put the kibosh on this thread quick. LOL

You are correct. Though I see three different things going on:

1) Your oservation..."I wouldn't pay $600 for any Daniel Winkler."
2) "I wouldn't pay $600 for that Daniel Winker."
3) "I wouldn't pay $600 for any knife."

For me, its moot. I don't have an extra 600 hundred bucks laying around.

If I did, I'd buy a set of SnapOn Steak Knife Wrenches.
 
Would you personally pay $625 for this specific knife?

Would I? No, because I don't have a need for it. If I wanted a chopper made by Daniel Winkler, then yes, I would. After all, I paid over $500 for my Chris Reeve carbon fiber Insingo, and that knive has titanium scales, and an S35V blade which is essentially the same materials menu that's included on my $220 ZT 0452cf. There just seems to be some sour grapes going on in this thread. "Well, I'd never pay..." ok, that's fine. Good deal. Guess what? There will be others who have no problem with the price, because they want a big chopper made by their favorite guy. Is what it is. Last time I looked around, pretty much EVERYthing in the knife world is more expensive these days.
 
You are correct. Though I see three different things going on:

1) Your oservation..."I wouldn't pay $600 for any Daniel Winkler."
2) "I wouldn't pay $600 for that Daniel Winker."
3) "I wouldn't pay $600 for any knife."

For me, its moot. I don't have an extra 600 hundred bucks laying around.

If I did, I'd buy a set of SnapOn Steak Knife Wrenches.

True. To me, it sort of starts to come off as a passive judgement towards those who would buy this knife. As I alluded to in my response to retzius, many of us have purchased knives that would make non-knife people think we were totally crazy. LOL Oh well, if ya want what ya want, ya pays what it costs. Also, it might seem that I'm bent outta shape about it, but I don't actually care. This is one of those situations where people-watching is giving me more information than the initial question that was asked.
 
I would absolutely love to have a knife from Mr. Winkler. Heck I've been looking at his WK2 belt knife for a long time and really wish I could have one. Daniel Winkler (as mentioned by marcinek) is an ABS Mastersmith, in the knife world, that means something. His full hand forged custom pieces go for a lot more than $625. Plus it is my understand that Mr. Winkler makes a lot of charitable contributions to soldiers abroad including steep discounts on his WK2 knife/hawk line. I have never seen anyone speak a bad word about the man either.

Everyone has their own opinion and that's good, opinions give us options in the knife world, and every has a dollar amount they attribute to value and that's good too. One of these days I would hope to own a Winkler blade. Maybe not today, but one day.
 
My answer would be no. But I have no problem with people who answer yes. Personally I would buy a Busse for that kind of money.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top