Jell-o Clips

I carry a utility knife with me at work along with my Endura. Sometimes you need a blade for a task you know will ruin the edge. I'd rather throw away a utility blade than spend an hour reprofiling mu carry knife.

Tasks like scraping something off of glass, cutting against metal or concrete, etc. are just better suited to a utility knife. The fragility of a pocket clip has never really been one of my concerns though.
Nothing wrong with that. I think most everyone here agrees that they aren't going to use a nicer knife for rough work that might damage it. It's just that's not what the thread is about. Aquaholic is asking why people avoid carrying knives with clips that could snag on something and then goes on to say he does exactly that by choosing to carry a utility knife when he's in a situation where a pocket clip might snag on something.

So basically he's asking in an insulting way why people do the same thing he does himself.
 
Amazingly I have only had this happen twice.
Once my seatbelt stole a Leek and put it under my seat and the other time I sprung a PM2 clip carrying a bundle of 2x4’s.

I’m a carpenter so I’m constantly crawling and climbing in tight spaces so I have to switch up knives and carry methods depending on what I am doing.
 
I switched over to carrying modern (read, clipped) folders around 2004 after having carried a slip-joint/SAK/Buck in pocket for most of my adult life. I'm a carpenter and have had a knife clipped in pocket both on and away from the job pretty much every day since. I've had a knife pulled out of pocket once in all that time, noticed it gone almost immediately, and found it clipped to something waist height when I re-traced my steps.

I had one clip get snagged and bent in a crowded lunch place when I got jostled by someone and pushed up against a counter. The clip on my large Sebenza 21 CF got bent out at almost a right angle. I'd only had the knife a week or so and carried it around like a wounded bird until I got back to the truck. I took the clip off, re-bent it as best I could, but it just wasn't right, so I got a new one from CRK.

As far as general use of folding knives on the job, probably 90% of knife work falls to a retractable razor knife which is what every carpenter and most construction workers carry on them as one of the big three along with a hammer and tape. It just works better for cutting felt, plastic, house wrap, shingles, insulation, etc. You also don't beat the crap out of your EDC and save it for those tasks it's better at.

Besides the clip, I usually have a pretty decent-sized lanyard hanging out of my pocket and haven't run into issues with it snagging and pulling the knife out either. In a tight space, I'll drop the knife securely into a pocket bottom or leave it behind. Up North, in our woods and fields, I'll generally carry a less-expensive and brightly colored knife as snags seem much more likely there.

Aside from a true, second-carry beater for scraping, pulling staples, etc, all my work knives are mid-tech and up save for a couple BMKs and Spydies in my regular rotation. When I need a good knife, that's just what I want available.
 
Ive never had this happen, but it has to my brother more than a few times.
If you met him you wouldn't question how it could happen though.
Haha I’ve got a buddy like that. He simply cannot keep a knife in “decent” condition. It baffles me how shatter brained he is, always placing not only his knife but other tools or whatever in the most precarious places.
Nothing wrong with that. I think most everyone here agrees that they aren't going to use a nicer knife for rough work that might damage it. It's just that's not what the thread is about. Aquaholic is asking why people avoid carrying knives with clips that could snag on something and then goes on to say he does exactly that by choosing to carry a utility knife when he's in a situation where a pocket clip might snag on something.

So basically he's asking in an insulting way why people do the same thing he does himself.
Hm it’s not that I’m worried the clip will snag on something when I’m under the house/in an attic but it’s more so just the surrounding environment isn’t suited to carry a “nicer edc” blade into...I never made claims that I was ever worried about my clip snagging thus me creating this post. But let’s get back on track here please.
 
I switched over to carrying modern (read, clipped) folders around 2004 after having carried a slip-joint/SAK/Buck in pocket for most of my adult life. I'm a carpenter and have had a knife clipped in pocket both on and away from the job pretty much every day since. I've had a knife pulled out of pocket once in all that time, noticed it gone almost immediately, and found it clipped to something waist height when I re-traced my steps.

I had one clip get snagged and bent in a crowded lunch place when I got jostled by someone and pushed up against a counter. The clip on my large Sebenza 21 CF got bent out at almost a right angle. I'd only had the knife a week or so and carried it around like a wounded bird until I got back to the truck. I took the clip off, re-bent it as best I could, but it just wasn't right, so I got a new one from CRK.

As far as general use of folding knives on the job, probably 90% of knife work falls to a retractable razor knife which is what every carpenter and most construction workers carry on them as one of the big three along with a hammer and tape. It just works better for cutting felt, plastic, house wrap, shingles, insulation, etc. You also don't beat the crap out of your EDC and save it for those tasks it's better at.

Besides the clip, I usually have a pretty decent-sized lanyard hanging out of my pocket and haven't run into issues with it snagging and pulling the knife out either. In a tight space, I'll drop the knife securely into a pocket bottom or leave it behind. Up North, in our woods and fields, I'll generally carry a less-expensive and brightly colored knife as snags seem much more likely there.

Aside from a true, second-carry beater for scraping, pulling staples, etc, all my work knives are mid-tech and up save for a couple BMKs and Spydies in my regular rotation. When I need a good knife, that's just what I want available.
Thanks for sharing Chazzy! I’m sorry to hear that happened to your Sebenza only after the first week. To me though if I’m understanding you correctly it seems like this was more of a pressure issue that caused the clip to bend? I’m still not understanding how the car seatbelt (which seems to be the most common culprit) is doing so much damage to everyone’s clips?!
 
I've had quite a few different knives get snagged on all sorts of shit. Couches, car seats/seat belts, trees/vines, doors/doorways.. A lot of shit. Gerber clips are designed to get snagged it seems. That's what caused the bulk of the accidents in the past. Plus they're mostly garbage so they bend like noodles(which in turn caused more snags!).

Just last week I snagged my 0900 on my couch's threading. Luckily I caught it before I stood up and either bent the clip or ripped the thread. I'd be surprised that this didn't happen at least once to people who carry their knives clipped.
 
Hm it’s not that I’m worried the clip will snag on something when I’m under the house/in an attic but it’s more so just the surrounding environment isn’t suited to carry a “nicer edc” blade into...I never made claims that I was ever worried about my clip snagging thus me creating this post. But let’s get back on track here please.
I was explaining that crawling through tight spaces like that while working was one of the ways a pocket clip could get snagged on something. If you were just talking about not wanting to get your pretty knife dirty or whatever then you are the one that took this conversation off topic.
 
I've had a ladder snag a knife out of my pocket and it fell on the ground. Never bent or broke one by snagging on anything though.
 
I've had a ladder snag a knife out of my pocket and it fell on the ground. Never bent or broke one by snagging on anything though.
I suppose I could see this happening if you where standing sideways and had your “carry pocket” up against the rungs. Is this what happened?

The only accident I’ve had and thankfully it was only the Rat is getting out of the car forgetting that said knife is in my lap and it taking a dive into the cement pool we call parking lots.
 
I fell asleep on the couch one day with a CS Pocket Bushman in my pocket. When I got up the clip snagged on one of the upholstery buttons on the couch and got bent pretty badly. Popped it off, bent it back, and reinstalled. I've also snagged a pocket clip once on a trash bag at work. I went to toss the bag (one of those large Hefty types) into the dumpster and the bag grabbed the clip as it passed the pocket. It pulled the knife out of my pocket, but the knife luckily fell on the ground and I retrieved it. Not so lucky with a small flashlight I had clipped in the same pocket a few years ago. It disappeard at work one night, and I'm sure it suffered the same fate, only the bag carried it all the way into the dumpster unnoticed. :( Them's the breaks.
 
These thing was designed to snag stuff. I've torn more belt loops off my pants than I can count on these damn things. I'm sure they claimed some pocket clips as well.

2MDK8_AS01
 
Thanks for sharing Chazzy! I’m sorry to hear that happened to your Sebenza only after the first week. To me though if I’m understanding you correctly it seems like this was more of a pressure issue that caused the clip to bend? I’m still not understanding how the car seatbelt (which seems to be the most common culprit) is doing so much damage to everyone’s clips?!

I see it a lot here in Texas. For whatever reason most folks opt for a vehicle that's as tall as their house. So the knife's in a front pocket, as they draw the seatbelt across it wiggles in under the exposed clip. Then, when they literally hop out of their vehicle, the clip finds itself suddenly under an immense load. It either bends, breaks or draws the knife out of the pocket.
 
I actually have a rather low set sedan, but this is exactly how my seat belt got me. It's weird because it only happens in my one car, the other is a crossover and it doesn't happen
 
It’s called momentum, that’s how it happens. It’s very understandable how it happens. People hit their elbow, knee, shin on stuff all the time. When ceiling joists are on 14” centers instead of 16”, things on the outside get hung up easily. Or when you have an access hole that you have to exhale in order to get through, it’s best not to have anything on the out side of your pants. That’s why I’ve learned to like a pocket slip for my knife. I like my knives a lot and prefer to keep possession of them and not have one of those oh crap moments
14" centers? How does that work?
I have come home with a six pack and found my Delica clipped to it as I slid it in the fridge.
 
Back
Top