Jim- nobody was running you down IMOP, just stating that the quality of product is not what this community calls adequate for the price or what is accepted here. It is hard to get this kind of criticism (my kydex sheaths have been called disgustingly ugly on here. It can be hard to be objective about what we create out of love and have a vested interest in. I'm sure that you care about your knives, after all you came here to face the fire, which I give you credit for. You have not hidden like so many others do, and that is a good thing. Don't take it personal, learn from what others have said here and strive to improve on the areas that need work. THe design seems solid to me, so a bit of fit and finish improvements would do a lot in increasing your good name. To me the blade scratches are the major fault that sticks out to me- if the blade isn't finished well it detracts from the whole knife- as I have found on all of my own knives and is the major area I wish to improve on.
Good luck in the future sir and keep improving and one day this thread may be seen as a major turning point for you- as long as you wish it to be one.
Kris