I remember back when Howard Clark first began making his L6 Bainite katana, and the huge hullabaloo over it (the “indestructible katana”. There used to be videos of one being used to chop cinder blocks etc. with folks rightly pointing out that traditionally forged katana wouldn’t withstand that kind of abuse. Don’t know what happened but I haven’t seen those videos in years).Being back in the US for a few days for the first time in a number of months, I've been comparing the K20 with the Swamp Rat Free Rein, both of which were waiting for me. It's really night and day. The K20 is properly balanced for a wakizashi. The Free Rein is still too blade heavy, despite the improvements on the earlier TNT-15. The K20 is precisely machined with a consistent edge. The Free Rein has the fit and finish of a Mora, and the edge thickens considerably towards the tip. The K20 handle is very well thought out - deceptively simple. The Free Rein handle is too narrow and slick, although there's a ready, ugly solution to that by wrapping with grip tape.
Granted, the Free Rein was only half the price of the K20, but it's still not a cheap blade. It should be a fun bush sword for messing around with outdoors, and TBH I'm far more likely to actually use it, but it's not in the same league as the K20.
If CPK ever makes a K30 katana with full guard (perhaps removable, screwing into the front of the handle), it would be a very expensive toy, but difficult to pass up.
The thing was that folks who acquired one and tested them, commented that while their chief advantage over more traditional katana, was the toughness, and resistance to taking a bend/set from a poor cut, their edge holding was beaten by many other decently made katana using other steels with conventional heat treats.
IIRC, HC’s L6 Bainite katanas had an edge hardness around 57-58hRc.
D3V is 60.5hRc. It still blows me away, to see the K18 flex test video. Until seeing that, I had no idea D3V was capable of that.
You generally always hear about the tradeoff between hardness vs brittleness. Toughness vs edge holding. Evil genius, indeed.
A K30 with a machined tsuba to match Nathan’s machined pommels…
