New Rules for the Exchange forum - Feedback thread.

Discussion in 'Tech Support, General Q&A, Site Feedback & More' started by Spark, Oct 30, 2010.

  1. Hombre Secreto

    Hombre Secreto

    236
    Oct 1, 2010
    I understand that legally there is nothing you can do, but we're not talking about a court of law here. What are the repercussions for people that engage in poor business practices here on bladeforums?
     
  2. Spark

    Spark HPIC - Hatas gonna Hate Staff Member Administrator Super Mod Moderator

    Oct 2, 1998
    If we feel it's warranted, we'll ban them.
     
  3. DowntownDM

    DowntownDM Banned BANNED

    May 11, 2007
    Exactly.

    Thank you.
     
  4. Darkfin

    Darkfin

    461
    Jan 20, 2004
    But therein lies the problem: How is "regularly" defined?

    Sure, some are obvious as per your example (selling 3-4 after every major knife show), but if you are going to have separate category/membership level for a "dealer", don't you also need a strict and specific definition of one (i.e. via a count of knives sold, or some other metric)? If not, it would seem that anyone who offers more than a few knives for sale on here annually is at risk of being accused of being a "dealer".

    Perhaps it would be easier to define the non-dealer--e.g. someone who sells less than x knives per year/month-- and anyone who does not fit into this category is automatically a dealer and should pony up....
     
  5. tundratrader

    tundratrader Banned BANNED

    Jan 10, 2009
    I think "regular" is very obvious to everyone.
     
  6. Spark

    Spark HPIC - Hatas gonna Hate Staff Member Administrator Super Mod Moderator

    Oct 2, 1998
    I'm not going to get nailed down in some super-specific "you can have X number of for sale threads a year" BS. Post history searches will make it readily apparent who's got a pattern of flipping knives, or selling multiples. For that matter, you guys are largely self policing in that regard, and the report button works.
     
  7. FLymon

    FLymon Gold Member Gold Member

    Aug 23, 2006
    Forgetting for a minute any ambiguity about who or what constitutes a dealer, these things seem about as black and white as it gets:

    "Rules for the Exchange forums - COMPLETELY REVISED, 10/30/2010"...

    "# The Seller is not allowed to reply to their own ad within 72 hours of anyone's post (including their own) for any reason. The 72 hour countdown for the seller restarts with each new reply to the thread by ANYONE."...

    "THESE RULES TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY."


    I am really interested to see how this rule in particular will effect the listings, but I don't see any infractions or warnings on threads that were started since 10/30/2010 and have MULTIPLE flagrant violations of just the 72 hour bump/reply rule.

    Maybe I am missing the enforcement of this, and just have not looked at the right threads?
    If not, when should we expect to see the enforcement begin?
     
  8. Esav Benyamin

    Esav Benyamin MidniteSuperMod

    Apr 6, 2000
    We have a small moderator staff. We cannot be everywhere all the time. We do rely on Report Post to find many violations. That said, you will be seeing more infractions for this as members have had a chance to read and understand the new instructions. Violating the no bump rule is a 10 point infraction.
     
  9. CL01

    CL01

    Apr 19, 2007
    I'm assuming these rules apply to the F/T threads as well as the F/S ones, right?

    So, once these new rules actually get followed, the F/T & F/S threads shouldn't get knocked down several pages so quickly. People asking questions, whether F/T offers or other questions, aren't to post in the thread, correct? They're supposed to email, PM, or VM the OP & get answered through the same channels.

    So, a F/T &/or F/S thread should only have the original post, possibly a "I'll take it", &/or a bump every 72 hrs. This should really simplify & unclutter things I would think.

    While it's not an issue to me, I do see deciding who's a Dealer & who isn't as not so clear cut. The idea of someone buying some knives "at full price" & selling some of them later sure doesn't seem like Dealer behavior. However, I'm guessing the Mods have certain people in mind when they mention it, not "some guy who's occasionally selling several knives."

    So, as someone else has already stated, there have been many violations (To these new rules), but it'll take time for everyone to be on board with this. Is there a grace period or a certain time where it's expected that everyone comply or the infractions start getting handed out?
     
  10. Esav Benyamin

    Esav Benyamin MidniteSuperMod

    Apr 6, 2000
    It will take time for everyone to be on board with this. New guys may get a break, especially on minor technical infractions. But they will also get told to READ THE FAQ AND EXCHANGE FORUM RULES! :)
     
  11. FLymon

    FLymon Gold Member Gold Member

    Aug 23, 2006
    I figured a warning with a strong suggestion to read the rules would be in order before a red flag, and I know there are limits to the ability to monitor the sight by the moderators. I also would be inclined to think most people violating the bump rule are just ignorant to the new rules. I didn't see the sticky, I happened to see this thread when I logged on and it happened to be at the top of the list of the Recent Thread list. If I had listed something for sale without stumbling on this thread I would probably be a violator myself.

    I don't even know if this is possible or feasible, but maybe everyone's account should be "locked out" of the exchange section until they acknowledge and agree to the new rules? Just a thought.
     
  12. Esav Benyamin

    Esav Benyamin MidniteSuperMod

    Apr 6, 2000
    We generally do give a yellow flag warning before a red flag infraction. But really, if I go to give someone a warning, their record pops up when I do that, and I see a number of warnings for other problems already --- well, they don't pay attention. Time for the infraction.
     
  13. CL01

    CL01

    Apr 19, 2007
    I would think these new rules are easier to monitor, too. Once this is fully implemented, FSorT threads should have very few posts in them.

    Once done, this "should" be pretty nice & keep threads from going down pages & pages at the end of a day.
     
  14. Spark

    Spark HPIC - Hatas gonna Hate Staff Member Administrator Super Mod Moderator

    Oct 2, 1998
    Really people can ask questions in the thread still - but the seller has to edit the answers into his previous post (preferably the OP). Buyers bumping threads hasn't been a huge issue except for chattering. Sellers and buyers getting in a back and forth, and the white noise "Message sent, message replied" crap on the other hand has lead to this problem.

    It's a lot like pornography. Defining it is difficult, but you can ID it when you see it.

    If the OP was before 10/31 then we'll probably let it slide, but if you see something, be part of the solution and report it. The faster everyone comes up to speed, the better.
     
  15. glockman99

    glockman99 Super Moderator Super Mod

    Jun 12, 2000
    Exactly!...This is how I roll. I also include: "Please read, and follow, the posted BF Exchange rules", when I issue a warning.
     
  16. LMT66

    LMT66 Gold Member Gold Member

    Jun 18, 2008
    Might I suggest that the new Revised Rules title be in bold red font at the top (or in bold blue) of all the Exchange pages. Not sure if that's possible but it isn't very visible as it is now.
     
    Last edited: Nov 5, 2010
  17. CL01

    CL01

    Apr 19, 2007
    I think I got it. Same rules apply for trade threads, too, right? So, all the "email sent" & in thread trade offers is not supposed to happen when this all gets fully absorbed by everyone, correct?

    Whether F/T or F/S, a poster can ask a question about the item(s) & the OP answers in edited OP (& should answer privately, by PM, VM, &/or email). However, on F/T threads specifically, people need to not post an offer in the thread, but take it privately, correct?

    Also, on F/T threads (F/S, too, for that matter), when an item is sold/traded, the OP should NOT post that it's gone, but only edit it in the OP, correct?

    Also, the 72 hr bump is from the last post, regardless of who posted (OP or others), correct?

    Sorry for all the questions still, but I think I messed up on a F/T thread, so I locked it closed.
     
  18. J_Curd

    J_Curd Gold Member Gold Member

    Jul 26, 2006
    I think eBay might have less rules now. Whoever caused this mess needs slapped.
     
  19. Esav Benyamin

    Esav Benyamin MidniteSuperMod

    Apr 6, 2000
    All your examples are correct.
     
  20. 2bkc

    2bkc

    516
    Oct 26, 2008
    What happens if we don't agree to the new rules? Will refunds be issued?
     

Share This Page