- Joined
- Sep 21, 2014
- Messages
- 3,108
I agree... But it's more like long time no knife for me. But I'm solving it too. The spine is 1080 powder with varying amounts of nickel thrown in to try to get a stormy sky...Long time no post, lets solve that!
The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is available! Price is $250 ea (shipped within CONUS).
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/
I agree... But it's more like long time no knife for me. But I'm solving it too. The spine is 1080 powder with varying amounts of nickel thrown in to try to get a stormy sky...Long time no post, lets solve that!
Yeah, I like that one!
Yup, posted about it in the thread about leather sewing.You got a sewing machine?
I thought it was just basically watered down ferric... It's not?Very carefully! LOL. I hesitated spending over $60 on a gallon of etchant, but decided to give it a try now that I am making my own damascus. Ferric works OK, but takes longer and leaves a rougher surface from the oxides. This stuff works fast, especially for test etches and will leave the surface smoother, which is nice for kitchen knives!


Stacy, I had some dilute FeCl that had gone old and didnt etch well since I hadnt used it for a while. I didnt have any more to mix and it would be a bit before I could get some, so I added some muriatic acid and hydrogen peroxide and it perked it up pretty good. It definitely acted different than just fecl, not better, just different. I havent experimented with it after that though. I added about 5% per volume of both (under ventilation..) and when I added the HO2, it fizzed and changed colour slightly.I recall a discussion with some folks who had chemical backgrounds and the consensus was that it was dilute HCl and a small amount iron, then after that has reacted adding a small amount of solid Ferric Chloride. The color would be the best way to figure how much FC it needs. It may need filtering or settling and decanting.
These are the simplified reactions:
Fe(II) (Elemental iron) added to dilute hydrochloric acid (HCl and H2O) = FeCl2 + H2 + H2O2. That would create Ferrous Chloride (Di-chloride) and HCL plus hydrogen peroxide. The peroxide breaks down to H2O plus O2, which recombines with the H2 to make water. Thus, you have an aqueous solution of Fe(II)Cl2 and HCl.
Our trusty Ferric Chloride - Fe(III)Cl3 added to dilute HCl = Fe(3) + 3Cl ions in the H2O which is a fancy way of saying it just dissolves. That would be the Ferric Chloride (Tri-Chloride), This ends up an aqueous solution of Fe(III) and HCL.
I will have to play with it someday, but I would say to try:
1 gallon of 10%-20% muriatic acid
1oz degreased steel wool
1oz solid FeCl3 (add a little at a time)
I bet there is an ounce or two of hydrogen peroxide added to speed things up.
Any thoughts Fitzo?
Nice! Are you addicted yet?First 2 blades forged out and heat treated from my first billet of damascus!