This is very cool Ryan...
In general I prefer my knives without a guard. That said, I've never had a knife of this style. My fixed blade knives, are designed and used for hunting, and for my personal use, the guard gets in the way.
But looking at the pictures in your first post, in my opinion, the knife looks really complete with the guard. Not that there was anything wrong with the original design, but it completely changes the knife, by adding the guard :thumbup:
San Mai steel.. :thumbup: Very cool. Can't wait to see this one finished