Get out the tar and feathers...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Also, you people posting GEC pictures and positivity need to cut it out. This is my thread, and I have been reliably informed that it is a hate thread. lol
Seriously though, you guys are off topic on the discussion about GEC. No offense, but there are plenty of other threads for posting your pretty pictures. This one is for discussion only, not for fawning over long pull Barlow pictures (or UK politics, or yadda yadda...).
 
This 68 had the bone splintering issue too . I remember being somewhat annoyed but got over it . I didn’t get injured though:) edit - probably handled at least 60 jigged gec’s over the years . Maybe 4 or 5 had this issue . I think the reason is fissures in the bone that become present at the buffing phase. I’d consider it a defect but they do get pocket worn fast .
View attachment 2142497
Yeah, it is certainly a defect.
 
The myriad baseless, nonsense, opinionated claims in this thread are truly impressive.

Hyperbole, it's the Best!!!
 
Sorry folks, but I have to say it. Great Eastern Cutlery is the most overrated thing since the Mona Lisa. :eek:

Before you start screaming at your computer, let me say one thing. I really like GEC knives! Sometimes. I have had a few, and they have been pretty nice overall. Some were not a good fit for me, but that was not their fault. In my experience, GEC knives have mostly had really nice fit and finish, good steel, and they are (theoretically) built to use. :) But....

1: They are just not as good as they are cracked up to be and the knives are sold as shelf queens, not to be used. I have seen plenty of issues with them on here and in person (ugly acrylic with ugly seams recently for instance). I had a 48 improved trapper that had really sharp jigging, almost splintery to the touch, and the secondary blade had an obnoxious and painfully sharp swedge that dug into your hand when you tried to actually use the knife (not just a problem on this one either, but pretty much any multi bladed Northfield). Recently, I got a Remington knife from them that the jigging actually did splinter! I reached in my pocket for it and a splinter of bone cracked off from around one of their lackluster pins and was stuck in my thumb! It was kind of painful and I had to use the knife to dig out the splinter of bone from the knife (oh the irony). Plus the shield is not fit perfectly either, with a gap beside it. They have non flush pins on every single knife that I know of. They have a lot of ugly, geometric type jigging (this is subjective though). Their blade tangs are so sharp that they are awful on your fingers in use, and on your pockets/leg when carrying. A lot of their knives have nail breaker pulls. Their warranty sucks, just give it a read. They won't even warranty a natural material handle (almost all of their knives) after use. People, knives are tools believe it or not. They are supposed to get used. That is not a warranty, it is worthless. That warranty is telling you to keep your knife a tube dwelling collectible.

2: They make so few knives! I know that they are a small operation and they do a lot of hand work, but dang. People crap on Case all the time for everything under the sun, but at least you can actually buy a Case! GEC makes so few knives that it is just silly, and it gives you no choice of what you want to buy. They sell knives more like they are art than tools. You will get what they make, and you had better like it. They could make the Farm and Field knives en masse so that people could actually get one to use, but they don't. Instead, they have raised prices and made it impossible to get a knife. They are tools. Imagine if wrenches were sold like boutique art like these are and how stupid that would be.

3: Fanboys and flippers. I have been looking at a bunch of GEC threads lately and it blows my mind what people will excuse if a knife has GEC stamped on it. It is like people are afraid that if they say something negative about the sacred cow that Bill Howard will personally ban them from flipping GEC's on Ebay or something. There is so much GEC butt kissing on Blade Forums it is crazy. I have seen people excuse flaws on knives like GEC/Bill Howard could never do anthing wrong. And the flippers are awful! Regular people with a life cannot find a GEC, so they get preyed on by douchebags flipping GEC's for insane prices.

I am going to stop ranting now. I actually like GEC knives themselves for the most part, but the company and the cult of GEC kind of sucks. I'm just saying that Case makes 10x as many knives, and they get crucified on here all the time while people give GEC a pass on most anything because they do not want to bad mouth the collector value out of their precious little untouched tubes. It is silly! I have GEC knives thanks to the exchange here, where you can sometimes find a knife for a decent price if you happen to show up to a sale thread at just the right time. I like them alot. I just don't get the cult. GEC, I'm not mad at you. I'm just dissapointed. lol Thanks for coming to my TED talk, now you can shun the non believer. :(

Thoughts? Please be nice by the way. We don't have to agree, but don't be a jerk to anyone.
I respect your opinion and understand what you write. Different strokes for different folks. I respect all of the opinions here, although I have not read all 9 pages, I still respect them.

Pros: They are works of art in the regard of good solid old school functionality. They have some basic solid designs that I am drawn to such as the 71.

Cons: I have never received one that is sharp and I have bought many. I really wish this would change. That is it for the cons list.

Your results may vary.
I will still usually buy any GEC I get my hands on.
 
On the whimsical knife note...
I kind of hate the whimsical knives. I would not mind if they made a zillion knives a year, then yeah, knock yourself out Bill. But they dont. So who the hell asked for a "Beerlow"??? It's a bad knife, and a dangerous bottle opener. lol
I thought I would hate the Beerlow, but it’s actually a very fun, unique knife. I’ve opened over a dozen beers with it, and have had no problem. I also like the unique way that the text is engraved on the blade. This feels like a one of a kind GEC, and it’s very fun to use.

Totally cool that you hate it, not all knives are for everyone. I can safely ignore the million Spyderco knives out there that I don’t give a crap about, but I’m also not going to start a thread talking about why I think they suck.
 
Too much BS to ever see the horizon in this thread Blues Blues . Some of these guys/gals/youngsters don't realize how fortunate it is that we still have solid cutlery companies in this country such as, Case, GEC, Bear & Son, etc. and seem to have forgotten the sudden slamming of the doors at Camillus and Schrade.
Or... we want them to do better so we are putting forth constructive criticism? That way, improvement occurs and no sudden door slamming happens.
 
Or... we want them to do better so we are putting forth constructive criticism?
“airing of the grievances” isn’t really constructive criticism, but then again it’s not going to shutter a successful business, either.

Also, I hope we all understand “feats of strength” is next in the celebration.
 
“airing of the grievances” isn’t really constructive criticism, but then again it’s not going to shutter a successful business, either.

Also, I hope we all understand “feats of strength” is next in the celebration.
6 of 1 and a half dozen of the other.
Feats of strength? Celebration? Huh? I didnt get the last part.
 
Also, you people posting GEC pictures and positivity need to cut it out. This is my thread, and I have been reliably informed that it is a hate thread. lol
Seriously though, you guys are off topic on the discussion about GEC. No offense, but there are plenty of other threads for posting your pretty pictures. This one is for discussion only, not for fawning over long pull Barlow pictures (or UK politics, or yadda yadda...).

Are you saying we aren't allowed to post pictures like this in this thread

Group 1 .jpg
Group 2 .jpg
Group 3 .jpg
Group 4 .jpg

but are allowed to post pictures like this in this thread

GEC Tidioute Scout Linerlock With End Cap 2 .jpg

Just making sure. Don't want to go astray here.
 
Are you saying we aren't allowed to post pictures like this in this thread

View attachment 2142932
View attachment 2142934
View attachment 2142935
View attachment 2142936

but are allowed to post pictures like this in this thread

View attachment 2142937

Just making sure. Don't want to go astray here.
The last one is fine, the others are off topic. As I said, only hate is allowed here. lol
Seriously though, relax bud. Unbunch your panties. People can disagree, we dont all have to fawn over GEC like they are a national treasure all the time. For example, I am betting that most of those knives came decently dull from the factory. lol
 
The last one is fine, the others are off topic. As I said, only hate is allowed here. lol
Seriously though, relax bud. Unbunch your panties. People can disagree, we dont all have to fawn over GEC like they are a national treasure all the time. For example, I am betting that most of those knives came decently dull from the factory. lol

Oh, I don't just fawn over GEC knives I also fawn over A. Wright knives

Sheffield Knives 8 .jpg

and Buck knives

Buck Group 1a .jpg

and don't get me started on Case knives

AA Case Group 1 .jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top