If you're going to make a recommendation like that's how the world should turn then at least be reasonable on who your audience is. And basing your recommendation on the Shinogi-Zukuri plane grind that is not widely available where as Hon-Zukuri convex is and is what most of us have.
For you to dismiss factory recommendations without testing it personally first is poor taste and I refuse to listen to your I'm smarter than Rockstead wildcat mentality.
You're an outlier using a piece of art in a construction zone, tragically romantic so I envy your freedom of expression. Your dollars your freedom so I get it, bravo.
But any enthusiasts reading this buy a Rockstead and enjoy it as art and extreme sharpness. Save a sub $100 Spyderco with a full flat S30V grind to cut rope, wire, tape, poly tubing, packages holding sand, grout and open cans.
So you hold on to the ball. I'm leaving the court. Pursuing Shirogorov knives next.
"Most" of us have either a Honzukuri or a Shinogizukuri, have you even read through this thread?
What are you even talking about? I've been carry my Rocksteads almost exclusively for months and have sharpened them several times. For
you to assume that I don't know what I'm talking about is poor taste.
I feel sorry that you look at your knives as "art" rather than "tools". Not all of us feel that way, and even though you act as you're trying to have a legitimate conversation, you come off as a know it all. I don't present my points as fact, I present them from experience (that you don't seem to have).
Sorry if I don't drink all the kool-aid regarding sharpening and an edge lasting 2-3 years. From experience, I know that it's a bunch of crap, sorry.
From the EdgeObserver.
http://www.edgeobserver.com/rockstead-higo-jh-zdp-189/
After handling several Rockstead knives the mastery of their manufacturing process becomes apparent. Each knife is ground with the same, high precision techniques that yield a perfect mirror finish. The surface looks more like something you would see on a hard-drive platter or other high tech component. A Rockstead representative at Blade Show let me know that the last mirroring stage is achieved by vibration lapping.
Vibra-lapping couples abrasive powders in a fluid suspension. This differs from the typical approach of having an abrasive impregnated or charged on a rotating wheel or belt. Its typically seen in lapidary or precision glass manufacturing.
The entire process isnt disclosed on the company website. They only state that they have developed specialty equipment for the manufacturing of their knives. I would assume that the majority of the shaping is produced via CNC. The bulk of their proprietary steps are likely in the finishing phase.
Regarding the edge, it is treated in a way that the entire bevel is regarded as the "edge". They might use a special process to achieve the polish, but the edge is the edge, plain and simple. I've sharpened many knives to be sharper than my Rockys on paper wheels following a mix of different compounds on the micron scale.
I've been sharpening by hand for many years and I
know what it takes to maintain the edge of a Rockstead. Nobody reinvented the wheel when Rocksteads were introduced to the market. Even Rockstead recommends using 2000 grit sandpaper to resharpen their knives, not
maintain,
resharpen. If you don't use your knives a lot and don't have experience in resharpening them, dont present yourself as having more experience than somebody that does have that experience.
Knowledge on sharpening goes a long way, and if you fail to understand the basics then you probably won't understand the methods I use. A convex zero grind is what Rockstead uses, if you know what that is, it's not hard to sharpen such a thing. It's not rocket-science like you seem to think it is...