This is a topic I've given much thought to.
I've concluded several things:
1) Some people in the woods are there to avoid the law! Illegal pot growers in the woods are on the rise.
2) There is no 911 in the woods.
3) There is no ammo resupply in the woods.
4) There are mulitple possible threats in the woods.
5) Some threats are larger than others.
6) The gun/ammo selected should be able to hit and neutralize any size threat.
7) Sheeple will be offended if they see your gun(s) or knife (knives)
8) Concealed carry should be possible with gun(s) selected.
9) Gun should be capable of being comfortably carried on the body, not in the pack.
10) The person should be proficient with the gun chosen. IE; be able to hit a sheet of paper at 25 yds.
11) Gun should be able to be seriously abused afield, and be easy to maintain if needed.
There are more conclusions, but these are the main ones.
The gun I selected after all was said and done was a Glock Model 20 chambered in 10mm. I reload, so my 10mm ammo is full power, unlike most of the stuff on store shelves.
I can conceal it in a KyTac (
www.kytac.com) holster, and it holds 15+1 Add 2 spare mags for another 30 shots and I have 46 shots in an easy to carry format. It is certainly powerful enough for people, dogs, rabid skunks and even the black bear that are in the woods I frequent.
If I were to run into the five drunks mentioned in a previous post and they wanted to do me harm, I'd be able to fight them off. How anyone would expect to do that with only 5 rds is beyond me.
My G-20 has the rail, so at night, I can affix my flashlight/laser onto it for night time ID and shooting.
The gun is durable. Drop any revolver on the rocks, you might just bend the crane enough to prevent function. If it then tumbles into the mud, it's going to be real gritty until you get it home or to a 'smith. The Glock, just swish it around in the stream and you're good to go.
Other situations allow for a different gun choice, but for an "all around, come-what-may" woods gun, the G-20 fills the bill for me.
.