Ah, I get the confusion. #1 was there to show that Mick Strider and Mickey Ray Burger are one and the same. That was to forestall any claims that the DD214 didn't belong to Mick Strider, or questions about "who's this Burger guy" - it's there for completeness. I'm not going to make statements on why Mick Strider needed a new name, or speculate on why anyone would have one or more aliases.
#2 has been proven correct. In my post here:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4353594&postcount=3
I even state that he served in C 2/75 and was honorably discharged. That said, Mick Strider's posted DD214 did contain factually incorrect information, and he mislead people as to the length of his service, nature of his service, etc. If it was just "Mick Strider claims to be a Ranger!" it wouldn't be a big deal. The whole mess starts in with "Mick Strider is a combat vet" and "has Special Operations experience" and "was in SOCOM" and all the rest.
#3, well, The FOIA documents show no combat time during his Army service.
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4353611&postcount=4 has quotes from the man himself. And his friend. The Chris Osman lawsuit is a pretty hard to refute there, but maybe it's possible that Mick Strider had non-US governmental combat service from 86-93. The question is where, when, and how, since spinal damaged, going AWOL, former E-1's with only 65 days in the Batt, who were barred from re-enlistment and have no special skills aren't exactly the ideal recruits to "go to war" or even be hired by contractors.
4-5 I think we're in agreement on.
I'll go one step further - I agree with you that it appears McClung has his own credibility issues, based on what I've read about his own service times. I can't see how someone can type out five instead of two, but hey, stranger things have happened. If you dig through the archives on BFC, there've been a few Kevin McClung threads in the past as well regarding knives and other issues. That's for another thread.
If you'd like to put together a thread detailing Kevin McClung's military claims, by all means go to town. I haven't seen him make claims about Somalia service or doing time and such, so my interest isn't exactly piqued right now, you know?
As for the Red Scorpion guy, if he won't give up his class date or other bonafides, and is making those claims, out his ass.