What Makes a Good, Traditional Barlow?

Great find, Sonny! I've tried to pick up both the yeller and black Buck granddaddies but found myself either in bidding wars that had gone beyond bananas or walking into a dealer who "knows things" about the knife and subsequently wants to ask for many times its fair market value. I believe those were Camillus builds? A fantastic example and, again, I find myself entertaining a little envy to my own consternation. :o

I did find a Barlow I've been trying to get for a while, and for a bang-up deal.
Thank you, and great find back at ya!!
Yes they were made by Camillus. I admit this cost more than I usually feel comfortable with, close to "beyond bananas" money actually, but like I said it was less than lots of other US-made knives these days. However, as with most of the Bucks I collect, I can't imagine they will ever lose value, especially those in good-used to NIB condition. Indeed, due to their relative rarity I'm sure they can only ultimately appreciate in value, so I try to look at it as an investment for my heirs, (heaven forbid I leave them any money, all they're gettin' is knives). in the last few years alone I have seen "vintage" knife values rise noticeably, with some of the non-SFO models I have more than doubling in value in the last three years alone. On top of that it's only the second yellow one I have seen available for sale in over a year, so I thought I should just knuckle under and snag it while I could, (and eat beans for a month; good thing I like beans). In coin collecting rarity is first, condition is second, I think that generally applies to vintage US-made knives too, (especially those no longer in production), and this qualifies on both counts. Simply stated, I won't spend that kind of money on a regular priced US-made knife, but for this rare bird I will.
 
Considering how much I saw one of those go for on the bay a little while ago (well north of 2 bills, IIRC) I can't imagine those big fellas will depreciate any time soon. It puts me in a pinch because as a Barlow collector I always want to get my hands on something like that but as someone who doesn't have a real focus on Buck or synthetic knives I tend to keep my purchases on the lower end of the price scale for those. However, I was willing to pay well over what I normally felt comfortable paying for a synthetic Barlow of recent vintage and yet I was still rapidly priced out of the game. I may have to readjust my expectations if I ever want to add one of those to my trove.

Glad you were able to give it a good home! :thumbup:
 
Considering how much I saw one of those go for on the bay a little while ago (well north of 2 bills, IIRC) I can't imagine those big fellas will depreciate any time soon. It puts me in a pinch because as a Barlow collector I always want to get my hands on something like that but as someone who doesn't have a real focus on Buck or synthetic knives I tend to keep my purchases on the lower end of the price scale for those. However, I was willing to pay well over what I normally felt comfortable paying for a synthetic Barlow of recent vintage and yet I was still rapidly priced out of the game. I may have to readjust my expectations if I ever want to add one of those to my trove.

Glad you were able to give it a good home! :thumbup:

I got lucky really, I got it for under a bill, (my black one too). I've fallen by the way side a few times too when they just keep going & going up into ridiculousness, (as they usually do). For some reason this listing didn't get noticed, or I suspect it would have gone higher. They didn't list the model number in the heading for one thing, so it fell through the usual-search-terms cracks I think. I actually found it when searching for another knife, and not in the search results, it was one of those small listings on the bottom of another Barlow's listing, (which I always check). Sometimes the way a listing is worded makes them not pop in search results, and others might only be found by accident or when searched for specifically. In fact I got quite a few of my knives at really good prices due to a badly worded listing, or one with poor photos. I also look for listings that end at odd times like 3 am on a Wednesday, often not that many people are out on the bay at that time so you can sometimes sneak in and score a deal. Actually, of my collection all but a few came out of the bay, and I got good deals on most by knowing what I was looking at, and knowing how the bay works. Knowledge is power!!

(Of course you know the last two posts I made were pure addictive justification. Guess I'm off the Knifeaholics Anonymous wagon again...back to step one).
 
Augie, great catch. All four are great in any condition. Somehow I like the Shapleigh a bit more. You should take group photo of your entire Barlow collection.

Mike
A real trove of Barlows, John! You would have to take a camera across the street to get all your Barlows in one picture!!:D

I agree with Paul that the Tested looks like a Utica-made knife!
 
Dean, Tim, Paul, Duncan, Mike, CDS, Nifebrite, TsarBomba, Charlie, Thank you all, appreciate all your kind comments. Duncan appreciate the encouragement friend.

I've got 2 more coming from this same collection, they all appear to be of the same era and all are in unused condition with varying degrees of storage rust, the 2 coming may be the best yet, we will see.

Nobody took a guess as to what makes the Boker special so I will spill the beans, It has 4 pins, have not come across another, most Bokers were 3 pin if bone and 2 pin if delrin. No idea as to why this one has 4.


IMG_5504_zpsbuf8nnvu.jpg




Charlie, looking at the Case I think this is the Case green bone from that era, any idea if it would start out as close to black when new? I took some pictures of the edges and it looks like the green to me. Do you think Case would have supplied the bone to Utica as I have not seen a Utica with this color bone before.


IMG_5530_zps7karh9h6.jpg



IMG_5529_zpsu1qtsxeh.jpg
 
Augie, great catch. All four are great in any condition. Somehow I like the Shapleigh a bit more. You should take group photo of your entire Barlow collection.

Mike

Mike, this is the best I can do right now, I hate to say it but I think there is enough for 2 more wheels.

IMG_5118_zpsvyehy0qq.jpg
 
Sonny, the Buck is a great find NIB, congrats.

TsarBomba, good pick up on the Colonial.
 
Mike, this is the best I can do right now, I hate to say it but I think there is enough for 2 more wheels.

IMG_5118_zpsvyehy0qq.jpg

WOW Amazing , thank you for sharing. There are quite a few I could feel comfortable in my pocket :cool: somehow I like the Russell barlows most, but couldn't find one in decent condition without breaking my bank account

Mike
 
John - A wonderful circle of Barlows my friend. You have been like a Barlow Magnet since I saw you last year at the rendezvous. :D
 
John - A wonderful circle of Barlows my friend. You have been like a Barlow Magnet since I saw you last year at the rendezvous. :D

Thank you Ron, really enjoyed last years Rendezvous and looking forward to this years. Robb, Mike, thanks a lot, appreciate it. Ed, hard to beat a Case Appaloosa, hell of a knife.
 
John beautiful vintage Barlows! That Barlow wheel is fabulous--post some more please. I love seeing a bunch of Barlows grouped together like in a wheel! So that is interesting your Boker example is a 4 pin Barlow so Boker made them with 2, 3 and four pins. I don't ever recall seeing a four pin variation. I have some 2 and 3 pin examples. Of your recent Barlow acquisitions three of the four pictured by you are four pin examples--very unique. What does the the tang stamp on the primary blade look like on that four pin? Barlows were most often made with three pins and some two pins like Imperial, Colonial, Kutmaster and Ka-Bar. In terms of four pin Barlows, I recall off hand that Queen uses or used four pins, many vintage Case Barlows were four pins and there are some others I can't think of right now. In modern times GEC Northfield Barlow 77s use four pins. All very interesting in terms of how they were made or configured by various knife makers. Thanks again for the beautiful photos, Lloyd
 
Queen is definitely using 4-pin construction on Barlows (#69 and #71):







Most of my Case standard Barlows are 3-pin, though. I don't think they've contracted any other makers for Barlows in the last 50 years or so (where there any Case Classic Barlows? :confused:). The granddaddy Barlows are 4-pin.





Even Sabre made 4-pin granddaddy Barlows (though their standard ones are 3-pin).

 
Last edited:
John beautiful vintage Barlows! That Barlow wheel is fabulous--post some more please. I love seeing a bunch of Barlows grouped together like in a wheel! So that is interesting your Boker example is a 4 pin Barlow so Boker made them with 2, 3 and four pins. I don't ever recall seeing a four pin variation. I have some 2 and 3 pin examples. Of your recent Barlow acquisitions three of the four pictured by you are four pin examples--very unique. What does the the tang stamp on the primary blade look like on that four pin? Barlows were most often made with three pins and some two pins like Imperial, Colonial, Kutmaster and Ka-Bar. In terms of four pin Barlows, I recall off hand that Queen uses or used four pins, many vintage Case Barlows were four pins and there are some others I can't think of right now. In modern times GEC Northfield Barlow 77s use four pins. All very interesting in terms of how they were made or configured by various knife makers. Thanks again for the beautiful photos, Lloyd


Thank you Lloyd, the Boker has no tang stamp other than the pattern number 493 which is correct as far as Boker's go. This is the second knife I've come across that is an anomaly as far as pins go, the other being a Winchester stamped Queen Barlow that only has 3 pins, I'm going to ask Bill Howard at the Rendezvous if he has any information on the knife as he was at Queen when the knife may have been made.

IMG_4404_zps3c5uiovh.jpg
 
Found another Drake Well Queen Barlow, these were made in 1972 to celebrate Queen's 50th anniversary, well made knives that have great looking bone.
Wish Queen would go back to this style bolster, set them apart from everyone else.

IMG_5539_zpszgvnvocp.jpg


IMG_5540_zps7e49iexi.jpg


IMG_5544_zps6jrxrxqo.jpg
 
Augie you're on a never ending roll~
Very nice Case ED


Even workhorse barlows need some TLC once in a while :)

tumblr_o84b1kbNW21rzq6m9o1_1280.jpg
 
Back
Top