Thanks for letting me know about the thread and thanks everyone for your thoughtful posts.
When we start getting into custom knives, it takes a while to understand that they are quite fragile ... They are strong if you are planning on edcing them, but keeping knives in new condition is surprisingly difficult. As I told the OP, it is very easy to cause some scuffs in anodized titanium while flipping it open and closed in a car while driving.
The OP came into my store and bought a custom knife. He spent 45 minutes to an hour going over 3-4 pieces in detail and picked one of them. He purchased it and we thought we had a happy customer. About an hour later, he calls because he feels the blade isn't well centered. We said to come on back and we'll figure it out. As best as I can guess, he had been flicking it a lot and the pivot loosened slightly. This said, I agreed to switch it out for a similar knife by the same maker that had a some filework on it (which raised the price by $15). He seemed totally happy with that. Then he changed his mind the next day.
Returns suck ... and we warned him right away when he called that it is really important that the knife is still in brand new condition. Our 3 day return policy is pretty clear that knives must be in entirely new condition if they will be returned. The return policy is really designed for customers buying knives on our website, who don't have the opportunity to inspect knives in person, but returns do happy in store every so often. Unfortunately, there is nothing worse for everyone concerned when someone wants to return a knife that they have damaged.
When the OP came back to the store, we looked it over together. He explained that despite spending a lot of time looking at, holding, and flicking the knife in the store, that he had decided the knife was too big. Unfortunately, the knife had some scuffing on the spine as well as two small scratches on the titanium liners. The scuffing on the spine isn't a big deal and can be easily fixed. The titanium liners are differentially anodized and fixing them will be a royal pain. Because the maker in in South Africa, we're going to have to get the knife back to South Africa, get it repaired and get it back there.
We normally don't take back damaged knives ... we don't sell damaged knives and getting knives repaired can take months. In this case, I made an exception because the customer was so upset. I estimated that the repair costs with shipping are likely to cost me about $200, not to mention, I will be unable to sell the knife for months. I offered that if he really wanted to return it, I would go through the effort of getting it repaired and offer him a cash refund minus the estimated repair costs. I honestly thought this would be appreciated. Instead, I got more and more unreasonable phone calls and texts today and finally threw up my hands and said some people can't be satisfied.
To be clear ... I think every part of this sucks. I've got a knife that is now slightly off centered (I'll have it fixed at Blade Show by the maker), and one that is scuffed, which will need to go back to Africa. For the OP, it sucks since I believe he genuinely doesn't realize that a new knife left my store and came back with cosmetic damage. Despite he and I looking at the knife at the store and looking at the damage, I think he honestly believes he didn't cause the scuffing. I thought the offer to take back a damaged knife and have him cover the repair costs would work out for everyone. Maybe if he reads through the thread it'll make more sense.
-daniel