Joking "Fatality!" posts aside, here are my two cents...
Regarding the original transaction/issue, dericdesmond should have been refunded the $11 difference for the USPS insurance he paid for (but which Liu Kang forgot to include). Offering to refund/reverse the entire transaction for the knife was a strange response, since as dericdesmond has stated many times he was perfectly happy with the knife he had paid for and received. What he wasn't happy with was a service (shipping carrier insurance) that he paid for but didn't receive, and the natural thing to do would be to provide a refund for that.
Having said that, I'm not sure why this thread was reopened nearly 1.5 years after it was posted. Liu Kang has suggested that it's in connection to some other dispute unrelated to this one and, it seems, on an entirely different forum. If this is the case, would someone -- whether one of the principals or someone else -- mind filling us in on what's happening? If the reason this thread was resurrected was a dispute on another forum rather than something on this forum, then given BladeForums' policy against cross-forum drama/disputes/etc., perhaps it should be locked up again.
Regarding the original transaction/issue, dericdesmond should have been refunded the $11 difference for the USPS insurance he paid for (but which Liu Kang forgot to include). Offering to refund/reverse the entire transaction for the knife was a strange response, since as dericdesmond has stated many times he was perfectly happy with the knife he had paid for and received. What he wasn't happy with was a service (shipping carrier insurance) that he paid for but didn't receive, and the natural thing to do would be to provide a refund for that.
Having said that, I'm not sure why this thread was reopened nearly 1.5 years after it was posted. Liu Kang has suggested that it's in connection to some other dispute unrelated to this one and, it seems, on an entirely different forum. If this is the case, would someone -- whether one of the principals or someone else -- mind filling us in on what's happening? If the reason this thread was resurrected was a dispute on another forum rather than something on this forum, then given BladeForums' policy against cross-forum drama/disputes/etc., perhaps it should be locked up again.
